Ghost Stories

It is not clear who is actually haunting the lighthouse but it certainly seems to have a mind of its own. The fog bell sounds by itself, and odd flickering lights can be seen when the lighthouse is empty, especially on the off-season. Years ago a horse died near the old lighthouse, and to this day people smell the horse of a scent and can hear it's whinnying and thumping of his hooves on the ground. The ghost of Naomi Coyler visits the island often. She used to swim from the island every morning to buy fresh lobsters from nearby sellers on boats, but in the early 1960's she never returned from her swim. Her body was indeed found floating, lifeless, on the ocean's surface, but her love of Baker's Island has kept her spirit alive and well. Witnesses say they have heard clanking sounds coming from where Naomi lived on the island, and once someone even saw her milk jug being placed under the water pump as the handle moved on its own and pumped water into the jug. A jewel thief is another famous ghost on the island. The thief hid his treasure on the island and in the light of a New England full moon, his ghost can be seen searching for the loot on certain nights. Sounds of a party from yesteryear, including music, laughter and the clatter of dishware is heard coming from the empty Chase House.

Gallows Hill - alleged location

Though the actual location where the public hangings took place can not be proven since there are no legal documents of the locality, Gallows Hill is believed by many to be in North Salem where a basketball court and playground are situated. Some say the actual hangings took place closer to where the Walgreens now sits on the corners of Boston and Proctor Streets which would have made the hanging tree near the original banks of the North River. Significant experiences have been had by many in the park area assumed to be Gallows Hill including visions of mist, orbs, hearing ethereal crying, electronic equipment malfunctioning in distinctly in this area, people have been touched, women's hair pulled and hundreds of photographs show what some people deem as ghosts, paranormal energies and angels.

Gardner-Pingree House

Built in 1804-1805 by a local merchant John Gardner Jr., the beautifully architected mansion is said to be haunted by Captain Joseph White who was brutally murdered in the lavish townhouse in 1830. Despite what some people say, historical records prove that Captain White was not married and was in the house alone when this heinous crime took place. Captain White's great nephew was too impatient to wait for his elderly, prosperous uncle to die naturally, so he took matters into his own hands by hiring a hit-man. The vicious assassin crept into Captain White's bedroom at night and struck the Captain's skull with a club, fracturing it, then ensured the Captain's death by stabbing him 13 times with a personally fashioned dagger. Some people believe this ghastly murder spectrally repeats itself each year on the anniversary of Captain White's death. Others say they have seen Captain White looking out the windows of his magnificent mansion, while some people claim to have captured his face gazing out the windows on camera while he observes the living on Essex Street. This murder became so infamous as Daniel Webster ingeniously prosecuted those involved in the massacre by setting a high standard in the courtroom at that time. The Gardner-Pingree House is now known as "The Clue" house given that its explicit history initiated thought into the Parker Brothers originating the board game, Clue.

You are viewing the text version of this site.

To view the full version please install the Adobe Flash Player and ensure your web browser has JavaScript enabled.

Need help? check the requirements page.


Get Flash Player